Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Power Forum - Renewable Energy Discussion

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

"Floating Neutral"

Featured Replies

I have 3  220v 4Watt Led lights in line. Each Led has a switch and use the same neutral.They all worked fine until I replaced 1 of the Led with a 1.06 Watt Led. Now if I switch on one of the 4Watt Led lights the 1.06Watt wil glow. I get a 3.22 volt L-N with the multimeter.Should I worry.

  • Replies 56
  • Views 11k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • To me it sounds as if your inverter is not properly earthed, or that multiple earths are used.  You should only have one earth reference, meaning the inverter should use your DB-panel earth.  If your

  • In German there is a saying:  Wehr Mist, mist viel Mist.   - He who measures, measures a lot of sh!t. You need to realise that electric lines carry not clean textbook stuff but very complex signa

  • Thanks. You raise a few interesting points and food for thought. I just think our lifestyle are of such a nature we want to do whatever we used to doing with the flick of a switch.  I have many t

Posted Images

1 hour ago, Chris Louw said:

I have 3  220v 4Watt Led lights in line. Each Led has a switch and use the same neutral.They all worked fine until I replaced 1 of the Led with a 1.06 Watt Led. Now if I switch on one of the 4Watt Led lights the 1.06Watt wil glow. I get a 3.22 volt L-N with the multimeter.Should I worry.

Maybe a typo L-N should be 220-240v N-E should be 0v

Edited by TaliaB

4 hours ago, TaliaB said:

Maybe a typo L-N should be 220-240v N-E should be 0v

@TaliaBNo the 3.22v is when it is switch off and one of the other LED lights is switched on. When switched on L-N 231v. When al the LED lights is switched off it is L-N 0v. Thanks for the reply. 

  • 2 weeks later...

I had a Sunsynk 5kW installed recently by a company listed as a Master Intaller .  However, I too have a similar issue with glowing LED lights throughout the house.  In my case however they glow all the time, load shedding or not.  There is no Earth-Neutral bond relay even though I did request it.  The backup circuit is on a split neutral.

Any ideas on this?  The installer seems too busy to resolve this so I am still withholding the final payment.  

  • Author
On 2023/02/17 at 4:01 PM, Modina said:

However, I am at the moment at a loss of words to try and explain massive differences on a AC meter reading by flipping the two meter probes.  Something is ammiss.  I would need to think about this.  Have you maybe got another meter you can try?  Sometimes the meter leads can break without you realizing it.  DC would then measure zero, but not AC.   A broken cable will have capacitive leakage across the break.  This capacitance will be enough to give you AC readings, even at low utility frequencies, i.e. nominal 50Hz.  But these readings will obviously be way out.  Cables always break where they flex the most, at the connector or probe junctions.  In a case like yours, one needs to check everything.

Hi. 

SoI bought a new multimeter (still cheapie, not Fluke) nd get the similar readings as before. Also the values change significantly when I switch around teh pos en neg leads. For example, with black lead on N and red lead on E, I get 0 V. When I switch the leads around, I get 90 V? This is during loadshedding. During normal operation when Eskom is online, all reading are as expect, and even with leads switched around.

 

 

 

 

@Leonb that is crazy.  Doesn't make any sense whatsoever.  Do you have a ghost looking over your shoulder? LOL.

The only way that I could explain it is if your wiring system that you measure is very high impedance, i.e. not really connected but picking up AC through stray capacitance and that that would create a voltage divider with the body-to-meter resistance.  When changing the probes, the capacitive coupling will likely change.

No, I don't  know what is happening in your measuring setup.  If you would tell me 1, 2 or 3 volts difference, maybe.  But 90V??   It's the weirdest thing I have heard in a long time.  Ghosts in the machine.

1 hour ago, Hubertus said:

I had a Sunsynk 5kW installed recently by a company listed as a Master Intaller .  However, I too have a similar issue with glowing LED lights throughout the house.  In my case however they glow all the time, load shedding or not.  There is no Earth-Neutral bond relay even though I did request it.  The backup circuit is on a split neutral.

Any ideas on this?  The installer seems too busy to resolve this so I am still withholding the final payment.  

1.LED bulbs vary a lot in quality. A low-quality LED may glow, buzz, or flicker even when switched off 2.The earth wire is at an extremely high resistance or the neutral wire is not bonded properly to the earth. 3.An electromagnetic induction may be causing a small pick-up of electricity from cables running along each other.

27 minutes ago, TaliaB said:

1.LED bulbs vary a lot in quality. A low-quality LED may glow, buzz, or flicker even when switched off 2.The earth wire is at an extremely high resistance or the neutral wire is not bonded properly to the earth. 3.An electromagnetic induction may be causing a small pick-up of electricity from cables running along each other.

That may be so, but none of them had that problem before the installation, and now they suddenly all glow.  I think I may have discovered the issue however.  My plug points on the backup circuit are reading 240V Neutral to  Earth. and 2V Live to Earth.  !?! 

1 hour ago, Hubertus said:

That may be so, but none of them had that problem before the installation, and now they suddenly all glow.  I think I may have discovered the issue however.  My plug points on the backup circuit are reading 240V Neutral to  Earth. and 2V Live to Earth.  !?! 

Definetly a problem with the earth either non existing or at very high resistance very dangerous situation need to get it fixed asap

  • 2 weeks later...
  • Author

Hi

Cab someone that understands this contactor please check if mine is wred properly? Blue/yellow is from inverter and red/black from grid.

I'm trying to follow the wring diagram, but not sure. And installer isnt pitching.

 

Many thanks.

 

20230311_155536.jpg

10 minutes ago, Leonb said:

Hi

Cab someone that understands this contactor please check if mine is wred properly? Blue/yellow is from inverter and red/black from grid.

I'm trying to follow the wring diagram, but not sure. And installer isnt pitching.

 

Many thanks.

 

20230311_155536.jpg

The yellow/green with blue lug  and the black with blue lug looks like the bond contact. The coil wires, the red and black on the right hand side, where do they come from.? 

Also you will have to send a high resolution  image of both the relay and its carrier board in order to figure out if the bond contact polarity is correct. 

 

Connected my grid as pic below and works perfectly. (Connected at the bottom and not from the top)

The rest of your wiring is all good.

EN Bond.jpg

Edited by GVC

  • Author

Two more photos, one from the top, the other from the bottom. To me this wiring does not make any sense. I mean, when the relay/contactor closes, it needs to create a bond between the E and inverter N. From the bottom view there is no N connected to relay, so where/how is this bond made when the grid falls away?

Does anyone maybe has a photo of how this box looks prewired, i.e. off the shelf. 

From the wiring diagram it states that grid L should be on no 4 and grid N on 5. This also doesn't make sense to me. How does 4 and 5 work together?

20230311_155539.jpg

20230311_155555.jpg

  • Author

Ok. Reading up a bit on this relay, I'm now convinced this installation is a f up. 

Either:

1) the eskom grid L/N need to be connected to the relay (A1 and A2) with the black wire (blue lug) on connector 1, or

2) the relay is powered from the inverter ATS240 pins, with the the black wire (blue lug) on connector 5.

 

On my installation nothing is connected to the relay to energize or de-energize it, so it cannot make a N/E bond when eskom drops.

 

Why the installer connected the grid to 5 and 8, I have no idea. 

 

Edited by Leonb

51 minutes ago, Leonb said:

Ok. Reading up a bit on this relay, I'm now convinced this installation is a f up. 

Either:

1) the eskom grid L/N need to be connected to the relay (A1 and A2) with the black wire (blue lug) on connector 1, or

2) the relay is powered from the inverter ATS240 pins, with the the black wire (blue lug) on connector 5.

 

On my installation nothing is connected to the relay to energize or de-energize it, so it cannot make a N/E bond when eskom drops.

 

Why the installer connected the grid to 5 and 8, I have no idea. 

 

I can see youve done your homework. Note :

when you using grid to power the relay you need a normally closed contact of the relay to bond neatral to earth.  

When you using ATS240,  you need a normally open contact as the ATS240 function energizes the relay when you need to bond. 

 

 

17 minutes ago, BritishRacingGreen said:

I can see youve done your homework. Note :

when you using grid to power the relay you need a normally closed contact of the relay to bond neatral to earth.  

When you using ATS240,  you need a normally open contact as the ATS240 function energizes the relay when you need to bond. 

 

 

I have noticed that many  installers qualified or unqualified, works with no specification at all, no schematic (not even a casual/informal one), no as-built drawings, no formal test and verification methods.  Some cannot tell you gridtie basics, yet they install and commission a gridtie. 

Really. In afrikaans we have a saying :

Ons weet nie wat ons doen nie, maar ons doen dit so lekker! 

Edited by BritishRacingGreen

2 hours ago, Leonb said:

On my installation nothing is connected to the relay to energize or de-energize it, so it cannot make a N/E bond when eskom drops.

Have you checked out this thread with pictures on how to connect it using the ATS240. 

 

Edited by GVC

  • Author
28 minutes ago, GVC said:

Have you checked out this thread with pictures on how to connect it using the ATS240. 

 

Yes, thanks, I have. 

From these and other threads I now think I understand how this relay/contactor works. My installer obviously not. I dont really want to rewire the box myself, and rather let him do it. But will as last resort.

 

Which of the two options is better: 1) using grid, or using ATS240 from inverter to operate the relay?. 

Mine is connected as per option 1.

The problem with option 1 is that when the grid returns, the relay in the Neutral box immediately switches but the Sunsynk takes a full minute before it kicks over to grid...therefore you once again have a floating neutral for that minute. I suppose one can reduce the time to a couple of seconds, but I like this 1 minute feature cos as we all know of the problems with power surges when the grid comes back online.

So, definitely option 2 is the better one.

Edited by GVC

1 hour ago, Leonb said:

Yes, thanks, I have. 

From these and other threads I now think I understand how this relay/contactor works. My installer obviously not. I dont really want to rewire the box myself, and rather let him do it. But will as last resort.

 

Which of the two options is better: 1) using grid, or using ATS240 from inverter to operate the relay?. 

Both the methods will perform the bonding function. 

Method 1 is safer though, as the bond is established when the relay de energizes. 

Method 2 is less safe as the relay is required energized to bond, so if the wire breaks to the coil or the ATS drive output fail, the bond will never make. And its undetectable, you wont know about it. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.