Shockin Posted July 24, 2020 Posted July 24, 2020 Hi Does anyone know anything about the Axpert Vp 5000/48 inverters, problems? Are they any good? Quote
Anonymous Posted July 24, 2020 Posted July 24, 2020 Hi in my personal opinion Axpert brand and type inverters are problematic and unreliable you are better off looking at Sunsynk Goodwe Solis or Kodak hybrids. Quote
wolfandy Posted July 24, 2020 Posted July 24, 2020 You will find many people running Axperts (or same unit under different brand, etc Mecer) Do some of them have problems? Yes, sure. Do all of them have problem? No Are there better units available? Sure. Are these more expensive? The ones I am aware of, yes Would I recommend an Axpert if money is not an obstacle? No. Would I recommend an Axpert if funds are limited? Yes I personally have been running an Axpert since 2015 without any major problem Quote
___ Posted July 24, 2020 Posted July 24, 2020 I like the Axperts. They usually turn into upgrades somewhere in the future GVC and wolfandy 1 1 Quote
Coulomb Posted July 25, 2020 Posted July 25, 2020 My vision at one point was for everyone to replace the capacitors and MOSFETs on all their Axperts before use. But of course, most people don't have the facilities to do this, and like to keep their warranty. So now only a few crackpots like me have done it, by the looks . I feel that the Axpert with capacitor and MOSFET mod, at roughly R1000 + labour, is a more reliable model than the factory one, and a far better value proposition. I wonder if one day one of the resellers will realise this, and order them from the manufacturer with these upgrades. It would then be only say R200 dearer (probably less), and of course there would be no labour involved in ripping out the lower spec'd parts. But perhaps the market will decide that "Meh. This model over here is R200 cheaper, and seems to do the same job. I'll buy that one and take my chances." ibiza 1 Quote
Coulomb Posted July 25, 2020 Posted July 25, 2020 21 hours ago, Shockin said: Does anyone know anything about the Axpert Vp 5000/48 inverters The VPs are "value line" PWM models. The PWM means you don't get maximum power point tracking (MPPT). There are a few die hards who believe that you get better power from a PWM system, but I'm certainly not one of them. You are also then confined to 2S wiring of your panels, and larger panels may be wasted on these PWM solar charge controllers because most of the time the panels are connected directly across the battery, and any extra voltage headroom is wasted. The price saving of a PWM model over the equivalent MPPT model is slight. The value line models can't be paralleled, so that's a consideration for the future. They may also have poorer fan control. Lastly, they are not popular models, so if there is a problem, there will be few other buyers to compare notes with, and firmware updates will be hard or impossible to obtain. So all in all: if your budget is desperately tight, it will probably do the job for you, just. If you can spend a little more, other models will be better value, in my opinion. I also agree with the other posters that if you have a lot of extra money to spend, or you demand high quality / long life, then other brands would be better choices. Quote
Chris Louw Posted August 4, 2020 Posted August 4, 2020 On 2020/07/25 at 2:38 PM, Coulomb said: I wonder if one day one of the resellers will realise this, and order them from the manufacturer with these upgrades. It would then be only say R200 dearer (probably less), and of course there would be no labour involved in ripping out the lower spec'd parts. But perhaps the market will decide that "Meh. This model over here is R200 cheaper, and seems to do the same job. I'll buy that one and take my chances." Recieved the capacitors and upgraded 1 inverter today . The MOSFETs K100E08N1 is not upgraded . Will do the spare inverter later this week . Coulomb 1 Quote
wolfandy Posted August 4, 2020 Posted August 4, 2020 15 minutes ago, Chris Louw said: Recieved the capacitors and upgraded 1 inverter today . The MOSFETs K100E08N1 is not upgraded . Will do the spare inverter later this week . Hi Chris would you mind helping me understand please what the benefit of the capacity (and MOSFET) upgrade is? Longevity? And if yes by approx how much? Any other benefits? Quote
Chris Louw Posted August 4, 2020 Posted August 4, 2020 This is a suggestion of @Coulomb . The existing capacitors have a life of 2000 hrs . The upgraded capacitors 10000 hrs . I believe a lot of MOSFET and driver breakdowns is caused by faulty capacitors . Coulomb is the electonic brain and I believe . Quote
wolfandy Posted August 4, 2020 Posted August 4, 2020 3 minutes ago, Chris Louw said: This is a suggestion of @Coulomb . The existing capacitors have a life of 2000 hrs . The upgraded capacitors 10000 hrs . I believe a lot of MOSFET and driver breakdowns is caused by faulty capacitors . Coulomb is the electonic brain and I believe . Great - thank you for the feedback Quote
wolfandy Posted August 4, 2020 Posted August 4, 2020 On 2020/07/25 at 2:38 PM, Coulomb said: My vision at one point was for everyone to replace the capacitors and MOSFETs on all their Axperts before use. But of course, most people don't have the facilities to do this, and like to keep their warranty. So now only a few crackpots like me have done it, by the looks . I feel that the Axpert with capacitor and MOSFET mod, at roughly R1000 + labour, is a more reliable model than the factory one, and a far better value proposition. One further question on this, @Coulomb (as I am trying to understand all related messages on AEVA): Are these capacitors only relevant to the MPPT-side of the Axpert or the overall DC-bus? Meaning that if I am not using the MPPT in the Axpert, would it still make sense to upgrade the capacitors to help increase the lifetime of the Axpert? Quote
Coulomb Posted August 4, 2020 Posted August 4, 2020 3 hours ago, wolfandy said: Are these capacitors only relevant to the MPPT-side of the Axpert or the overall DC-bus? No. They mainly protect the MOSFETs that form the low voltage end of the battery-to-bus DC-DC converter. Quote Meaning that if I am not using the MPPT in the Axpert, would it still make sense to upgrade the capacitors to help increase the lifetime of the Axpert? Yes, it's still worth the upgrade. wolfandy 1 Quote
wolfandy Posted August 5, 2020 Posted August 5, 2020 8 hours ago, Coulomb said: Yes, it's still worth the upgrade. Thank you for the feedback Then I will try to find someone in my neck of the woods that can do the replacement for me Quote
wolfandy Posted August 10, 2020 Posted August 10, 2020 One follow-up question, @Coulomb: Is my understanding correct that the caps are the ones as per below (from page 12 of the Axpert service manual)? I've found someone locally that can do the replacement for me and the shipment from Mouser should arrive during the course of this week Quote
Coulomb Posted August 11, 2020 Posted August 11, 2020 22 hours ago, wolfandy said: Is my understanding correct that the caps are the ones as per below... Yes, that's the ones that protect the MOSFETs, and that you should replace. 22 hours ago, wolfandy said: I've found someone locally that can do the replacement for me Great! Quote
wolfandy Posted August 11, 2020 Posted August 11, 2020 8 hours ago, Coulomb said: Yes, that's the ones that protect the MOSFETs, and that you should replace. Thank you Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.